Napoleonic Wargaming for fun and Little Cold Wars- book reviews.

As I enjoyed my short stint as Napoleon so much in the Pennine Megagame’s Jena 1806 (see an earlier post) I decided to pick up a copy of Paddy Griffith’s Napoleonic Wargaming for Fun from the History of Wargaming Project. Whilst it is really not my period (other than a fondness for the Ridley Scott film The Duellists and subsequent desire to do a retreat from Moscow skirmish campaign) I was intrigued by the inclusion in the book of high level games hence my purchasing of it.

The late Paddy Griffith seems to have a reputation in gaming circles as something of an iconoclast famously and publicly swearing off miniatures gaming sometime in the 80’s. This book (the HoWP being a reprint) pre dates that proclamation as half of the book deals with miniatures games; that it was republished within his lifetime implies to me that he still saw some worth in what he wrote and he was not as dogmatic as his reputation at times suggested.

As alluded to earlier the book is a compilation of seven rule sets all on the theme of Napoleonic land warfare, they cover different scales of engagement, starting with the skirmish level, passing through, brigade, division and army level, all of which are miniatures games the book concludes with a generalship game, Kreigspiel and advice on TEWTs (Tactical Exercises Without Troops). It was these last three I was interested in. Not that I am giving up on miniatures, I’m still keen on the toy soldiers but for one thing I’ve not got the space for a giant collection in another period. Rather I’m wanting to use the Napoleonic Wars to add a bit of variety to my gaming.

Dealing with the first four sets of rules first they are very straightforward games, interestingly it is noted that apart from a few special circumstances/ theatres there is not that much scope for little actions within the Napoleonic period and even Brigade and Divisional actions are best assumed to be part of a much larger action. Being honest this middle part doesn’t interest me much. My gaming interests lie at either extreme, the larger extreme being adequately covered by the Army game, also the shortest of the four miniatures rules. Indicative of the time it was written perhaps is the fact that you would still have a multitude of little bases to move about. If I were to dabble at this level in 6mm I’d want to have more figures representing a higher formation to speed play. In any event this rules set would form an ideal starting point.

Following on from this is my favourite part of the book: the generalship game. Essentially it is a time management roleplay where you have to plan your day as a general running a campaign against an opponent who is doing the same. I’d love to use this system to re run the Jena campaign, also the example used in the book, I think it is eminently possible, maybe as a PBEM too.

The nineteenth century origins of Kriegspiel are well known enough now for me to not detail them further. Unsurprisingly playing the 1824 Kriegspiel is something I’ve wanted to do for a long time but like many things remains on my gaming wishlist Paddy Griffith’s notes and observations makes me want to get organised and put on a game. Any pointers as to where I could get the blocks to play the game with would be much appreciated.

The final section deals with yet another part of gaming that I want to try but have yet to do so a TWET, essential a country walk with a moderated battle taking place in the participant’s mind’s eye(s). It has a similar heritage to the Kriegspiel in that it originated as a training technique for nineteenth century officers, known then as a staff ride. I think how ever I shall wait until someone offers to run one of these locally as I fear any attempt to dive in at the deep end myself and run one would be a little beyond me.

Overall the book is ideal for those wanting a little more from gaming, I think that in today’s hobby market the miniatures rules themselves are unlikely to get any new adherents, the market is not structured in that way. However they still have worth as examples of rule sets written by a professional (i.e., holds a PHD in History) historian rather than an enthusiastic amateur, not to belittle the latter rather I want to highlight the different viewpoint that the (rarer) professional historian who also writes rules brings. In gaming as well as his academic work Paddy Griffith wasn’t afraid to follow his convictions even if they went against the orthodoxy (at this point I’ll recommend his ‘Forward in to Battle’).

On a completely different tack but in the same order I bought a copy of Little Cold Wars: Wargaming the Cold War using Toy Soldiers by Tim Gow and Betrand Plastique. This rule set takes a nostalgic and delightfully whimsical approach to the often technologically obsessed genre of Cold War gaming. Channelling HG Wells the authors have developed hybrid of a floor game with toy soldiers to the warm glow of remembering a childhood living under the bomb. Eschewing dice for all but the Close Combat mechanisms Little Cold Wars sees a mix of scales (1/35th for toy soldiers, 1/48th for vehicles, 1/72nd for aircraft) do battle by matchstick firing cannon, dropping darts into targets and throwing scrunched up bits of paper. The thing is it really works, I can vouch for this having played an early playtest version of the rules.

Early hobby gaming all started out by using physical props to determine the results of combat, it was not until after WW2 that the dice rolling obsession took hold. It is really pleasing to see a return to these mechanisms are carefully put together is a game that relies on two lots of nostalgia, not that any gamers alive today would have played any HG Wells style games pre war so that nostalgia at least is vicarious. Being 11 and just starting at secondary school when the Berlin Wall was opened I am probably amongst the youngest gamers who remember the Cold War with any clarity, I’d be interested as to what a millennial would make of Little Cold Wars. My uncle was in the Army in Berlin at the time it was knocked down and brought a piece back for me which I still have.

[A little piece has broken off from the larger lump which gave me the idea to crush it up and mix it with plaster to create a scale model of a section of the wall to have a physical link to the place on the table top]

Either way it is a game I want to play myself, albeit all in 20mm, though I need to assemble a few props and toy cannon… and buy some silly hats… I just wish I still had my DDR flag too.

Both books are available here:



7 comments on “Napoleonic Wargaming for fun and Little Cold Wars- book reviews.

  1. Matevz Groselj says:

    A very interesting post, while I have to admit my interest in all-things-military rarely goes above company level, I do find the aspect of military campaigns quite interesting.

    Alas, I did a quick search for your blocks:

    If it doesn’t take you where it should, they are in Irregular miniatures home page -> Misc & Making a master (bottom page) -> Bases & Kriegspiel blocks (left hand side)

    Theres also more on Kriegsspiel here:

    For blocks it might be worth looking at mdf cut maybe?

  2. Matevz Groselj says:

    Err, I think my original comment disappeared (if you have to approve it, just ignore this one then).

    This was a very interesting post and for someone mostly interested in small unit tactics, I was quite interested in reading about Military campaigns – that’s a whole new hobby all together, but it could well be used in combination with miniature games, so each game in campaign (not Military campaign) would have some logic behind it.

    Block can be found at Irregular miniatures:

    If link doesn’t take you there go home page -> misc&mould making (bottom page) -> bases & kriegsspiel blocks (left hand side menu).

    There’s also more on Kriegsspiel here:

  3. Matevz Groselj says:

    Okay this is the third comment I am writing, it just wouldn’t post them (I apologise if they all post later on).

    To sum it up this time, very interesting aspect to gaming, a whole new hobby.

    Kriegsspiel blocks are sold by Irregular miniatures. I think perhaps link prevents me from commenting. So go home page – Misc&Mould making (bottom page) – Bases&k.s blocks (left hand side).

    There’s more on kriegsspiel on too fat lardies page.

  4. Pete S/ SP says:

    Thanks for all your comments and persistance Matevz. The problem was that for some reason your first two comments needed moderation (they shouldn’t have) but your third didn’t. No idea why, I can only apologise.

    Linking the smaller tabletop battles together with a larger high level campaign sounds like a great idea. Something to work on.

    I’ve picked up the basic Too Fatt Lardies Package with rules, scenario and map. I found some very nice mdf cut blocks from the US but with the pound doing so badly I may have to wait a while before I order. In the meantime I should have thought about Irregular- they do almost everything. I’ll order a set.



  5. Rupert says:

    Hi Pete, we should meet up – as I have retreat from Russia skirmish rules and have been playtesting two army level wargames rules with the aim of getting the perfect one (if there is such a thing!!) on a sepperate note Ive ran a few walkabout wargames (did part of Waterloo on North York Moors! which was hilarious – I also have a the 1798 landing at Fishguard (the ‘last invasijon of Britain’) to run ..So Id be really keen on meeting up to test some rules, some scales, some ideas! Ill e-mail. Rupe

  6. Pete S/ SP says:

    Sounds great to me on all counts Rupert. Refighting Waterloo on the North York moors sounds great.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s